By 
Let’s get straight to the point: If you’re in the market for a diesel-powered 4×4, the Mahindra Thar Roxx is your go-to choice. On the other hand, if a petrol-powered 4×4 is what you seek, the Maruti Suzuki Jimny should be at the top of your list. The reason for this simple decision lies in the limited options—while the Jimny doesn’t offer a diesel variant, the Roxx’s petrol version lacks 4×4 capability. So, if you already know your preferred fuel type, your decision is straightforward.
However, if fuel type isn’t a deciding factor for you, choosing between these two vehicles can be a bit more complex. But don’t worry, we’re here to simplify things for you. Before we dive in, it’s important to note that while the Thar Roxx and the Jimny are both 4x4s, they cater to different needs and lifestyles. Consequently, they appeal to buyers for distinct reasons.
In this article, we’ll outline these reasons—some critical, some minor, but all relevant. To make it easier to digest, we’ve narrowed it down to five key reasons for choosing each vehicle.
Why Choose the Jimny:
- Comfort is a Priority: The Jimny’s suspension is tuned for a softer ride, making it more comfortable at lower to medium speeds. It absorbs bumps well and doesn’t jostle you around as much as the Thar does. Load it up, and it gets even better. Plus, its interior ergonomics and consistent quality further enhance the comfort factor.
- You Prefer Tight, Technical Trails: Both the Roxx and the Jimny are equipped with solid 4×4 systems and can tackle various terrains. However, when it comes to narrow, technical trails, the Jimny’s smaller size and lighter weight give it a distinct advantage.
- You’re an iPhone User: This might seem trivial, but it’s a valid point. The Jimny supports wireless Android Auto and Apple CarPlay, while the Thar is yet to offer wireless CarPlay. If seamless integration with your iPhone is crucial to you, the Jimny wins this round.
- Fuel Efficiency Matters: While the Jimny may not be the most fuel-efficient vehicle by Maruti standards, it still delivers over 12 km/l in the city. In contrast, the Roxx struggles to hit 10 km/l, despite being a diesel. On longer drives, the difference is less noticeable, with both vehicles averaging around 15 km/l.
- You’re on a Budget: This is a big one. When comparing top-spec models, the Jimny is significantly more affordable than the Roxx. With current discounts, the Jimny could even cost nearly half as much as the Roxx. But don’t be mistaken—the Jimny offers great value without feeling like half the SUV.
Why Choose the Thar Roxx:
- Power, Torque, and a Rugged SUV Feel: The Thar Roxx’s diesel engine is a powerhouse—smooth, modern, and incredibly capable. It easily propels the hefty SUV to impressive speeds and handles tough climbs and challenging terrain without breaking a sweat. The six-speed automatic transmission is a perfect match for this engine, making the Roxx a joy to drive.
- You Want Modern Features: If you’re looking for a 4×4 packed with the latest features, the Roxx is the way to go. From electrically adjustable and cooled seats to a panoramic sunroof, wireless charging, a cooled glovebox, and a full-color TFT driver information system, the Roxx has it all. Despite its old-school exterior, it’s a tech-savvy vehicle on the inside.
- You Need Space for Five and Luggage: If you require a true five-seater, the Jimny is out of the running, as Maruti officially classifies it as a four-seater. The Thar Roxx, however, comfortably accommodates five adults and still offers ample luggage space. Its rear bench is spacious, with a reclining seatback, and there’s plenty of knee and headroom. Plus, the boot is large and well-shaped, perfect for packing up for a long trip.
- You Want to Make a Statement: There’s no denying that the Roxx has a commanding presence on the road. Its long wheelbase, 19-inch wheels, and muscular, blocky design make it impossible to ignore. If making a bold statement is important to you, the Roxx is the clear choice.
In conclusion, both the Mahindra Thar Roxx and the Maruti Suzuki Jimny offer unique advantages depending on your needs. Whether you prioritize comfort, modern features, or a rugged, powerful drive, there’s a 4×4 here for you.
